In the News

DSC Media Coverage

05/17/2013

Staff and students in Philadelphia are protesting a Draconian budget proposal that would leave many schools without arts or music, without secretaries or aides, and without libraries in the 2013-14 school year. Dozens of teachers gathered near a high school this morning to protest, according to NBC Philadelphia, and students in the 138,000-student district are planning a walkout for later today. More than 1,000 students were expected to walk out of school at noon, said Beth Patel, a spokeswoman for the Philadelphia Student Union. Students plan to meet at the school district and walk to City Hall, where Philadelphia's city council is hearing testimony on the impact of the proposed budget cuts, she said.

05/14/2013

(Teresa Watanabe, Los Angeles Times, 05/14/13) In ground-breaking action, the Los Angeles Unified school board voted Tuesday to ban suspensions of defiant students, directing officials to use alternative disciplinary practices instead. The packed board room erupted in cheers after the 5-2 vote to approve the proposal, which made L.A. Unified the first school district in the state to ban defiance as grounds for suspension. The action comes amid mounting national concern that removing students from school is imperiling their academic achievement and disproportionately harming minority students, particularly African Americans.

05/12/2013

(Teresa Watanabe, Los Angeles Times 05/12/13) Damien Valentine knows painfully well about a national phenomenon that is imperiling the academic achievement of minority students, particularly African Americans like himself: the pervasive and disproportionate use of suspensions from school for mouthing off and other acts of defiance. The Manual Arts Senior High School sophomore has been suspended several times beginning in seventh grade, when he was sent home for a day and a half for refusing to change his seat because he was talking. He said the suspensions never helped him learn to control his behavior but only made him fall further behind.

05/08/2013

(Rebecca Klein, Huffington Post, 05/08/13) Anthony Weiner may not be an official candidate in the New York City mayoral race, but the policies he would hypothetically enact are already drawing opposition. Members of the Urban Youth Collaborative (UYC) and New Yorkers for Great Public Schools protested outside of Weiner’s Park Avenue South apartment Monday afternoon in response to a position he described in his “Keys To The City” policy paper, The New York Times reports.

05/07/2013

(Vernon Clark, Philadelphia Inquirer, 05/17/13) A swelling crowd of thousands of Philadelphia public school students left their classes at noon Friday and marched outside the district headquarters on North Broad Street to protest proposed education cuts. Chanting "Save Our Schools" and "No education, no life," the students attracted supportive "honks" from drivers passing the mid-day scene. The orderly crowd shut down traffic as it moved south on Broad Street toward City Hall and rallied in the building's courtyard.

04/24/2013

(Sally Lee (Teachers Unite), Huffington Post, 4/24/13) Not long ago a New Haven, Conn., high school with a predominantly African-American student body had an annex for students with chronic absences and those labeled as having behavioral issues. The annex was located in the New Haven Armory, which was a functioning military armory used to store vehicles, weapons and live ammunition. From this location students would look out a window and have a close-up view of the jail and juvenile court next door. Sometimes they would see friends or neighbors there. Students and teachers alike hated the school's location and the stigma they felt because of it. In 2006 the New Haven School District conceded to youth demands to relocate the school.

04/16/2013

(Democracy Now, 04/16/2013) A group of New York City students, organizers and officials gathered Monday to condemn the school-to-prison pipeline they say is funneling students of color into the criminal justice system. Members of the Dignity in Schools Campaign have drawn attention to the disproportionate number of suspensions and arrests of African-American and Latino students as well as harsh penalties against students with disabilities. In the last school year, 52 percent of suspensions involved African-American students, who make up just 27 percent of the public school system. Democracy Now! spoke with 15-year-old youth leader Manny Yusuf.

04/16/2013

(Emma Sokoloff-Rubin, Gotham Schools, 04/16/2013) After years of pressing Mayor Bloomberg to make school discipline fairer, students and advocates are turning their attention to the candidates seeking to replace him. At a rally outside City Hall just before a City Council hearing on school climate Monday, students and advocates the Dignity in Schools Campaign called on the next mayor to take a different approach to school discipline. They want a model that relies less on suspensions and other punitive measures, and also ensures that black and Latino students are not disproportionately affected by school discipline.

04/15/2013

(Javier C. Hernandez, City Room - New York Times, 04/16/2013) Four Democratic candidates for mayor on Monday used such terms to denounce elements of student discipline in New York City’s schools, saying black and Latino students’ suspensions were disproportionately high and principals imposed unnecessarily harsh penalties on students with disabilities. “We’re suspending students far too often,” Mr. Thompson, who was the Democratic nominee for mayor in 2009, said at a City Hall news conference organized by Dignity in Schools, an advocacy group.

04/04/2013

(Annie Gowen, Washington Post, 4/4/2013) The small band of guerrilla photographers spread out in schools across the District, snapping photos of metal detectors, police pat-downs, and scuffles between security guards and students. The dozen or so teens, who hail from some of the area’s most troubled neighborhoods, are trying to document the kind of school security issues that have taken center stage in the wake of the Newtown, Conn., shootings.

04/02/2013

(Eliza Shapiro, 04/02/2013, The Daily Beast) Leslie Mendoza, now 17, says she felt like she was entering a prison every time she entered her magnet public high school in Los Angeles. Police would even search students’ backpacks and pockets when they came to school late. “That was one of the things that made me not want to go to school anymore,” she says. She dropped out of high school when she was 15, though she eventually earned her degree at another school. “At our school we don’t allow any police in without a warrant,” she says.

04/01/2013

(Lanetra Bennett, WCTV-TV, 04/01/2013) Community leaders across the country are saying "NO" to guns in schools. The groups say arming teachers or staff does not mean school safety.Civil rights and education groups in Florida say something needs to be done to keep school kids safe. But, they say legislation (HB 1097) to allow designated school employees to carry guns is not the answer. "That indeed is a bad idea." Says, Shirley Johnson with the Florida State Conference of the NAACP. During a teleconference Monday, Johnson, along with members of Advancement Project, and Dream Defenders, rejected House Bill 1097. They say it could lead to unintended consequences.

03/26/2013

(Jennifer H. Cunningham, New York Daily News, 3/26/2013)  Arrests and summonses in Bronx public schools have dropped by more than half in the first quarter of the school year, NYPD data show. But the borough still led the city with the most arrests and summonses in schools, according to statistics the NYPD released to the City Council.

02/15/2013

(Craig D. Frazier, Amsterdam News, 2/15/2013) Controversy regarding the high number of children suspended in New York City schools continues. Since 2009, the Dignity in Schools Campaign-New York (DSC-NY), a coalition of educators, advocacy and parent groups, have led a campaign pushing for funding and implementation of positive, school-wide approaches to discipline that improves school climate, reduces conflict and increases learning in city schools.

02/03/2013

(Zaina Alsous, The Daily Tar Heel, 2/03/13) Last week The New York Post splashed the image of 7-year-old Wilson Reyes in handcuffs on its cover. Reyes was accused of stealing $5 from another student and was then interrogated by police officers. While this case may seem extreme, the core issues — criminalization of youth and unjust school disciplinary practices — are widespread and have been occurring for years.

01/25/2013

(James Cersonsky, AlterNet, 1/25/2013) In the wake of the Newtown massacre, municipalities far away, and far different, from Newtown are now ramping up their school police forces and security checks. They have an ally in President Obama, whose 23 gun control proposals include added funding for “school resource officers”—that is, police. As a result, students of color across the country are bracing for the dependably discriminatory impact of heightened school security. Since the advent of zero-tolerance policies during the Reagan-era war on drugs, suspension rates have gone up disproportionately for blacks, Latinos and Native Americans. Black students are now three times as likely as white students to get suspended, despite scant evidence of greater suspension-worthy infraction. The policies undergirding this discrimination are twofold: first, codes of conduct with heavy penalties for nonviolent incidents like being late, talking back, violating dress codes, or, as Daniel Denvir writes at Vice, farting; second, more school police to enforce them—a 38 percent national increase from 1997 to 2007.

01/23/2013

(Rebecca Burns, In These Times, 1/23/13) Schools have redefined developmentally appropriate behaviors as crimes. Pushing and shoving in the schoolyard is now a battery, and talking back is now disorderly conduct. Metal detectors and uniformed security guards greet students each day at Orr Academy on Chicago’s West Side. “My high school seemed like its own personal prison,” Edward Ward, a 2011 Orr graduate, told the Senate Judiciary Committee during his testimony in December 2012. He recalled how a police processing center was even set up to book students on school grounds.

01/23/2013

(John Kelly, Chronicle of Social Change, 01/23/13) Some congressional leaders and juvenile advocates are trying to include community-based youth programs in the public dialogue about gun rights and control, while also pushing back against the concept of placing police in schools. Reps. Bobby Scott (D-Va.) and Mike Thompson (D-Calif.) held a summit on Capitol Hill yesterday to promote the Youth Prison Reduction through Opportunities, Mentoring, Intervention, Support, and Education Act (the Youth PROMISE Act), Scott’s bill to fund community-developed action plans to reduce violence in high-crime areas. Meanwhile, a slate of organizations have circulated statements and held conference calls with the media to voice opposition to the prospect of stationing police at every school.

01/11/2013

(Felicia Sonmez, Washington Post, 1/11/13) A coalition of advocacy groups including the NAACP Legal Defense Fund is pushing back against the idea of upping the number of armed police officers in schools, a suggestion being considered by the White House in the wake of the Newtown, Conn., shooting tragedy. The groups – which include the Advancement Project, the Dignity in Schools Campaign and the Alliance for Educational Justice – released an issue brief Friday in which they warn of the “unintended consequences” of a greater police presence in schools, such as increased criminalization of students.

01/10/2013

(Julianne Hing, Colorlines, 1/10/13) It wasn’t just students who returned to school this week after their holiday break. In school districts around the country, extra police officers are being deployed to provide a sense of security while policymakers weigh legislation in response to the massacre in Newtown, Conn.—proposals that could make police in schools an increased and permanent fixture in kids’ lives. Politicians’ response to the deadly attack unleashed on Sandy Hook Elementary in December has been swift. This week, Vice President Joe Biden convened meetings for a White House task force to address gun access and mental health issues, and has promised to deliver a legislative proposal to the president by month’s end.

12/13/2012

By Nirvi Shah, Education Week, 12/13/12

At a U.S. Senate hearing Wednesday about ending the 'school-to-prison pipeline,' leaders in the U.S. Departments of Education and Justice said they expect to provide guidance to schools about school discipline policies, a measure that would add to the growing list of actions the current administration has taken in this arena.

12/13/2012

By Julianne Hing, ColorLines, 12/13/12

12/13/2012

(Inside Story Americas, Al Jazeera English, 12/13/12) For the first time, a US congressional panel is looking into what the American Civil Liberties Union calls a disturbing trend - one that criminalises rather than educates many US children. Edward Ward, a Chicago youth organiser, explains: "I’ve actually seen where in schools they treat the students like prisoners. And when you treat students like prisoners or criminals, you don't get results, you get consequences."

12/13/2012

By Donna St. George, Washington Post, 12/13/12

At a congressional hearing billed as the first-ever focused on ending the “school-to-prison pipeline,” Edward Ward emerged as a voice of experience.

11/16/2012

(NY1 News, 11/16/12) Fewer students are getting suspended from city schools, according to new numbers from the New York City Department of Education. The Dignity for Schools Campaign says the number of suspensions among minority students is still disproportionately high.

10/16/2012

(By Lennin Reyes, The Bronx Journal Reporter, 10/16/12) On a crisp Friday evening in October, pedestrians enjoying a stroll along the Brooklyn Bridge heard the chanting of hundreds of youths in green shirts: “Solutions not suspensions!” It was New York City students, marching against “pushouts” as part of a nationwide Dignity in Schools campaign.

10/10/2012

(Bob Geary, Opinion Column, IndyWeek, 10/10/2012) Fittingly, as the King service ended, a demonstration was beginning downtown for a cause to which Carolyn would've subscribed. NC HEAT's March Against School Pushout was part of a national campaign to challenge the school-to-prison pipeline, which results in disproportionate numbers of low-income, minority and LGBT students being suspended, expelled and drawn into crime.

10/07/2012

(News 14 Carolina, 10/07/2012) A group of Triangle students spoke out about issues impacting young people at a rally on Saturday.
N.C. HEAT, or Heroes Emerging Among Teens marched as part of Dignity in School's National Week of Action Against School Pushout. Organizers said they're shedding light on suspensions among minorities and policies that lead to high dropout rates.

10/04/2012

(By Laura Isensee, Miami Herald, 10/04/2012) Dozens of students and residents marched from Booker T. Washington Senior High to the site of the future Children’s Courthouse downtown, as they called for a stop to out-of-school suspensions. There is growing national concern that suspensions can limit a student’s educational progress, lower their likelihood of graduating and increase the chance they will end up in jail.

10/04/2012

(Joe Malinconico, Paterson Press, 10/04/2012) Thirty-seven percent of the students at School 11 were suspended during the 2010-11 academic year, according to data on the state education department’s website. At School 10, the number was 28 percent and at School 6 it was 25 percent. The state average for elementary schools was four percent, according to the education department.

10/04/2012

(Nirvi Shah, Education Week, 10/04/2012) Responding to state and national concerns about the effects of out-of-school suspensions on students' education trajectories, California has adopted several measures attempting to change the way that form of school discipline is used. Concerns linger, though, that Gov. Jerry Brown's veto of one related bill may undermine the others.

10/04/2012

(Mary Frost, Brooklyn Daily Eagle, 10/04/2012) Roughly a thousand kids are suspended every week in New York City schools and advocacy groups say these suspensions are unnecessarily harsh, especially for black and Latino students.This Friday night, members of the Dignity in Schools Campaign New York (DSC-NY) will hold a candlelight vigil and march across the Brooklyn Bridge to protest the suspensions. About a dozen groups are involved, including Advocates for Children of New York, American Friends Service Committee, Children's Defense Fund and Make the Road New York.

10/03/2012

(Cari Hachmann, The Portland Observer, 10/03/2012) Portland Parent Union founder Sheila Warren (right) with her husband Ronald Warren and granddaughter Paris Warren work to end school suspensions and create alternatives for youth at risk of being pushed out of critical learning opportunities. The Portland Parents Union invites the public to attend a meeting on Saturday, Oct. 6 in northeast Portland to educate and discuss alternatives to school “pushouts,” a description for the disproportionate number of minority youth who are suspended or expelled from school by zero-tolerance policies.

10/02/2012

(The Skanner News, October 02, 2012) The Portland Parents Union, a member of the Dignity in Schools coalition, is observing the National Week of Action on School Push-out with  a “restorative listening” event on disproportionate suspensions and expulsions of students, Saturday, Oct. 6, 4 p.m. at Westminster Presbyterian Church, 1624 NE Hancock. The event starts with a news and informational session, and continues through the evening with students and families sharing their stories and participating in a facilitated restorative listening process designed to speed up the healing process for students, families and the community at large.

10/02/2012

(Nirvi Shah, Education Week, 10/02/2012)The Dignity in Schools campaign is observing its third annual week of action, with events planned in at least 20 cities to call attention to the 3 million out-of-school suspensions from public schools each year. The organization is marking the week with rallies, trainings, and other events in cities including Chicago, Denver, Los Angeles, Miami, and New Orleans. But this year's events coincide with a very specific request from these organizations: They want a ban on suspensions for at least a year. The groups want schools to replace suspension with a variety of other approaches. The organizations told me recently that students can't afford to continue being kept from school while schools figure out what effective discipline looks like.

10/01/2012

(Brandon Campbell, Progress Illinois, 10/01/2012) A group of student activists and their advocates marched from Crane High School to a nearby Cook County Juvenile Detention Center to protest student suspensions and pushouts on Saturday. The activists are targeting schools that indefinitely suspend, or pushout, chronically truant or low-performing students, sometimes in a effort to raise overall school performance.

09/28/2012

(Vanessa Romo, Southern California Public Radio, 9/28/2012) A national coalition of youth groups, educators and advocacy organizations is launching the 3rd Annual National Week of Action on School Pushout starting tomorrow.

09/25/2012

(Michael Holzman‚ BeyondChron, 9/25/2012) A new report from the Schott Foundation for Public Education finds that only 52 percent of Black male and 58 percent of Latino male ninth-graders graduate from high school four years later, while 78 percent of White, on-Latino male ninth-graders graduate four years later. The report suggests that without a policy framework that creates opportunity for all students, strengthens supports for the teaching profession and strikes the ight balance between support-based reforms and standards-driven reforms, the U.S. will become increasingly unequal and less competitive in the global economy.

09/04/2012

(Jason Silverstein, Huffington Post, 09/04/2012) As the school year begins, so does the Dignity in Schools and Opportunity to Learn Campaigns' "Solutions Not Suspensions" initiative to combat the dramatic racial disparities in school punishments. In schools across the country, youth of color are arrested more aggressively, tried more severely, and sentenced more harshly than white youths. The ACLU's Racial Justice Program calls this national trend the "school to prison pipeline," though The Children's Defense Fund believes life chances dwindle even before the classroom - at the cradle. By adopting more constructive disciplinary policies, the campaigns reason, schools can interrupt the criminalization of youth, combat the persistent achievement gap, and steer children away from an unforgiving justice system. As the school year begins, we should question why we readily discard so much human potential, funneling some children into prisons while redeeming others, considering some children 'pranksters' and others 'criminals.'

09/04/2012

(Marisa Treviño, LatinaLista, 09/04/12) The school year is just getting underway and two education groups are hoping that this school year will be different for those Latino, African American and disabled children for whom out-of-school suspension has become the norm rather than the exception. The Dignity in Schools Campaign (DSC) and the Opportunity to Learn Campaign have joined forces launching a grassroots initiative calling for a national moratorium on out-of-school suspensions.

08/29/2012

(Patrick Wall, DNAinfo, 8/29/2012) City officials have agreed to consider far-reaching changes to school discipline policies, including how school safety agents are trained and what offenses students can be ticketed for, following a series of meetings between school and police officials as well as parents and students.

The summer meetings were prompted by protests earlier in the year when NYPD data showed that in late 2011 police officers arrested an average of five students per day, the vast majority of whom were black or Latino. The police averaged four student arrests and seven summonses per day for the full school year, according to a report this month.

08/27/2012

(Tim Walker, NEAToday, 8/27/2012) The Solutions Not Suspensions initiative, announced last Tuesday at an event led by the Dignity in Schools Campaign (DSC) and the Opportunity to Learn Campaign in Los Angeles, comes on the heels of a series of reports exposing the dramatic racial disparities in school suspensions. Earlier this year, the Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights’ survey found that Black students are more than three-and-a-half times as likely as white students to be suspended or expelled, In addition, more than 70 percent of students arrested in school were Black or Hispanic. Civil rights advocates have long argued that these punitive actions only exacerbate the achievement gap, contribute to high dropout rates and increase the likelihood of student arrests and referrals to the juvenile justice system.

08/22/2012

(Nirvi Shah, Education Week, 8/22/2012) Several national groups are asking school districts to stop suspending students out of school and replace this form of discipline with what they consider to be "more constructive" approaches that benefit students, teachers, and communities. The New York-based Dignity in Schools Campaign launched its call for a moratorium on out-of-school suspension at a gathering in Los Angeles on Tuesday, joined by more than 50 other groups.

08/21/2012

(Esmeralda Fabián, Diario La Opinion, 08/21/2012 ) Son más de 3 millones de estudiantes los que, de acuerdo con recientes estudios, son suspendidos de la escuela cada año en el país; la mayoría de ellos son estudiantes latinos y afroamericanos. Esto ha provocado que pierdan días de instrucción y que algunos nunca lleguen a graduarse.

08/07/2012

(Nirvi Shah and Lesli A. Maxwell, Education Week, 08/07/2012) Nearly one in six African-American students was suspended from school during the 2009-10 academic year, more than three times the rate of their white peers, a new analysis of federal education data has found. That compares with about one in 20 white students, researchers at the Civil Rights Project/Proyecto Derechos Civiles, based at the University of California, Los Angeles, conclude. They use data collected from about half of all school districts in the nation for that year by the U.S. Department of Education’s office for civil rights.

07/30/2012

(Kaile Shilling,  Los Angeles Magazine, 7/30/2012) Here in Los Angeles, we’re certainly no stranger to tension between local communities and law enforcement (see: MacArthur Park, 2007; South Los Angeles, 1992; Watts 1965), but things have been getting better. Crime has plummeted in recent years, and relations between the police and the public—especially in minority communities—are warmer than they have been in decades. The Violence Protection Coalition of Greater L.A.’s Community Safety Scorecard, which measures neighborhood safety, gives a picture of where we are today. Below are some things that have worked here and could help Anaheim.

07/17/2012

Kim McGill, an organizer with the Youth Justice Coalition of Los Angeles, discusses recruiting and training young organizers around the issues of the juvenile injustice system, police and prison funding, the school to prison pipeline, what it means to build a movement led by people and communities of color, especially youth of color.

07/06/2012

(Fix School Discipline, 07/06/2012 ) If given final approval by the Legislature and signed by the Governor, the bills will lead to positive discipline accountability alternatives for students in schools with the most out-of-school suspensions, better data for communities and policy makers working to keep students on track to graduate, and a much-needed change to “willful defiance,” one of more than 24 school removal categories that accounts for more than 40% of all school suspensions and as much as 12% of all expulsions. 

07/02/2012

(Manuel Criollo, 07/02/2012) A coalition of parents, students and civil rights groups representing the Dignity in Schools Campaign said California's largest school district is "leading the way for the state" after school board members voted unanimously late Thursday, June 28, to support statewide legislation to reduce the high number of out of school suspensions. The vote of confidence from LAUSD board members added momentum to seven bills currently in the California Legislature.

06/26/2012

(League of Education Voters, The Sacramento Bee, 06/26/2012)  A bold new approach to discipline at Lincoln High School in Walla Walla, Washington, has revolutionized the lives of its students. The film Resilient: The School Discipline Revolution in Walla Walla, WA, tells the story of how Lincoln High School, a small alternative school in Walla Walla, was able to reduce its suspension rates by 85 percent, almost entirely eliminate expulsions, and increase graduation rates.

06/14/2012

(Craig D. Frazier, Amsterdam News, 06/14/2012) Last week, students, parents, educators and elected officials rallied at a press conference outside a Department of Education (DOE) hearing at Stuyvesant High School. Students with the Dignity in Schools Campaign-New York (DSC-NY) testified at the public hearing on the newly revised School Discipline Code and demanded positive alternatives to the high suspension rates in New York City schools.

06/06/2012

(Theodoric Meyer, Schoolbook/New York Times, 06/06/2012) About 100 parents, teachers, students and advocates turned out for a hearing at Stuyvesant High School on Tuesday evening on proposed changes to the city’s discipline code, which would, among other things, lessen the number of offenses for which students could be suspended.

06/05/2012

(Lindsey Christ, NY1, 06/05/2012) A public meeting was held in Lower Manhattan Tuesday night about proposed changes to the Department of Education's discipline code, as the department's statistics show that a disproportionate number of students of color are being suspended. Students, advocates and civil libertarians have been concerned about the rate of suspensions for a while. Last year, 73,000 students in city public schools were suspended.

06/05/2012

(Kamelia Kilawan, Gotham Gazette,  06/05/2012) “Changes made are minor and won’t provide systemic change,” said Sarah Landes, a member of the Dignity in Schools Campaign, a collection of teachers, students and youth organizations working to reduce suspension and mandate alternative discipline methods. Shoshi Chowdhury, coordinator for the Dignity in Schools Campaign, said the punishment of suspension should end for the first three levels of school misconduct, including insubordination, pushing and shoving. Suspension should be a last resort as it allows many students to fall behind in schools, she said. In cases of level 4 and 5 fighting in schools, positive alternatives should be offered.

06/05/2012

(Avni Bhatia, Advocates for Children of New York, 06/05/2012) Today I am going to speak about Dignity in Schools New York’s overall impressions of this year’s draft Discipline Code.  Over the past several years, our campaign has been meeting with the Office of School and Youth Development to ask for changes to the Discipline Code that would lead to a shift away from schools’ use of punishment and exclusion and towards positive, school-wide approaches to discipline and safety that improve school climate, reduce conflict, and increase learning. Our members are pleased that the draft of the 2012-2013 Discipline Code contains the most significant changes we have seen to the Code since we began meeting with OSYD. We applaud the DOE’s work to reflect in this draft a concrete move away from harsh, punitive policies and towards more constructive approaches to discipline. 

05/31/2012

(Corinne Lestch, New York Daily News, 05/31/2012) Most of the students arrested or ticketed by police are in Bronx schools, according to a new analysis of NYPD school safety data released by the New York Civil Liberties Union. The report, released Wednesday, shows that 33% of arrests were made and nearly 55% of summonses were given in the Bronx. Citywide, police arrested 327 students and handed out 555 summonses in schools from January through March.

05/30/2012

(James Swift, Youth Today, 05/30/2012) A new report based on research of three California school districts suggests that school children exposed to so called, “zero tolerance” policies may be taking a toll on their mental health and wellbeing.

 

03/13/2012

(Dinu Ahmed, Huffington Post, 3/13/2012) On March 8, 2012, the New Settlement Parent Action Committee gathered 100 parents, students, educators, and elected officials on the steps of the Bronx Borough President's office to express their outrage over the Bronx's shocking rates of school-based arrests and student summonses, and to demand positive disciplinary alternatives. Recent data released under the Student Safety Act -- new legislation that disaggregates statistics on arrests and summonses by race, age, and gender -- shows the disproportionate impact that harsh punitive measures in New York City schools have had on the Bronx, particularly on youth of color. Out of a whopping 532 summonses issued to New York City students to appear in court during the last three months of 2011, the Bronx alone accounted for nearly half of all cases. 63% of those summonses were for charges of "disorderly conduct." Unbelievably, 93.5% of the nearly 300 students arrested in the same time period were either Black or Latino - and here too, the Bronx topped the list as the borough with the highest percentage of school-based arrests.

03/01/2012

(Cyril Josh Barker, Amsterdam News, 03/01/2012)  A campaign made up of public school students, teachers, parents and City Council members released startling data about arrests and summons in schools. The criticism stems from the Student Safety Act, enacted in 2011, which requires the NYPD to submit quarterly reports to the City Council on arrests, summonses and other police-student interactions in the schools. Last week, the Dignity in Schools Campaign-New York held a press conference at One Police Plaza in Lower Manhattan demanding better school safety policies. Data show that when it comes to policing in schools, students of color are being targeted.

03/01/2012

(Gail Robinson, Huffington Post, 03/01/2012) As they have sought to remake the nation's largest public school system, New York City officials have portrayed their efforts as a civil rights struggle. But despite such rhetoric, the city has created an obstacle course for its students, especially black and Latino boys, and the barriers these young men must navigate have little or nothing to do with academics. The record offers a sharp counterpoint to Mayor Michael Bloomberg's launching last summer of a wide-ranging initiative to "tackle the broad disparities slowing the advancement of black and Latino young men." Under his administration the city has stepped up policies that many believe have increased those disparities, suspending or even jailing black and Latino students for transgressions that a generation ago might have ended with a sharp talk in the dean's office. Last week provided still more evidence of this as advocacy groups released figures from the New York City Police Department on the numbers of arrests in city public schools for the last three months of 2011.

02/18/2012

(By Jason Keyser, Associated Press, 02/18/2012) About 100 students, teachers and community activists staged a sit-in Saturday at a struggling Chicago school to try to block a takeover by the city meant to turn around the school's poor performance. The protesters -- most of whom pitched tents outside, while 15 others holed up inside the building -- said the planned takeover by a nonprofit academy working for the city government would likely mean cuts to special education and bilingual programs.

01/25/2012

(By Linda Paul, WBEZ, 01/25/2012) If you look at all Chicago arrests of juveniles in 2010, a fifth occurred on Chicago Public Schools property. That’s way too many arrests, according to a report out from Project NIA, a Chicago-based advocacy group that works against incarceration of kids. The Chicago police department data that NIA crunched found 5,574 juvenile arrests on CPS property in 2010. Of those arrests, about three-quarters involved African-American youth, even though black students comprise 45 percent of the school population.

01/05/2012

(By Annette Fuentes, Rethinking Schools 01/05/12) A week before classes ended last spring, 13-year-old Diana Nava was waiting with her mother, Modesto, for the Los Angeles city bus that goes near her school. Even though her mother had awakened Diana early, she was behind schedule. An LA police officer patrolling for truants spotted them at the bus stop and gave Diana a ticket for violating the city’s daytime curfew. “My mother said, ‘She’s on her way to school’ but the officer said it didn’t matter.” For being late, Nava and her mother would have to go to court and face a $250 fine, a loss in time and money they could ill afford.

11/23/2011

(Kathy Mulady, Equal Voice Newspaper, 11/23/2011) At a time when competition for jobs is fierce and even entry-level positions require a high school or college degree, anyone without a high school diploma need not apply. Yet, each year, more than a million students in the United States leave high school without graduating. Once assumed to be dropouts, many who leave are, in reality, pushed out.

11/15/2011

(By Robin Urevich, HealthyCal.org, 11/15/2011) In Los Angeles, a change in the city’s daytime curfew law is on the City Council agenda. The law is aimed at keeping kids in school, but activists have waged a two-year battle against it, saying it’s punitive, discriminatory and counter-productive. For years, students who were on the street after classes started, even those who were rushing toward school, faced a $250 fine. Their parents were forced to miss work to attend court hearings.

11/03/2011

(Jenifer Carnig, NYCLU, 11/03/2011) The New York Civil Liberties Union today called on NYPD Commissioner Ray Kelly to stop delaying and comply with the Student Safety Act, a law that requires the Police Department to release quarterly reports detailing its activity in city schools. The NYPD has missed two consecutive reporting deadline.

10/20/2011

(L.A. Times Blog, Los Angeles Times, 10/20/2011) The new policy, announced Thursday, is the latest change from a campaign to reform traditional school discipline that advocates say results in ethnic and racial profiling and hardships for students and families. The targeted old rules were part of a get-tough philosophy that included truancy sweeps, $250 tickets and mandatory court appearances that could potentially result in jail time for parents. Such measures, advocates said, can diminish time in school and ultimately increase the dropout rate.

10/12/2011

(Jorge Rivas, Color Lines, 10/12/2011) School suspensions for non-white students in grades K-12 have increased by more than 100 percent since 1970. That’s according to a recent report highlighted by TheRoot.com. The report, "Discipline policies, Successful Schools, and Racial Justice" was conducted by the National Education Policy Center. The report uses data from the U.S. Department of Education’s Civil Rights Office, along with figures collected under No Child Left Behind and a sampling of state education agencies to illustrate the widening disciplinary gap between students of color and their white counterparts.

10/11/2011

(Melanie Asmar, Denver Times, 10/11/2011) School discipline, once considered too lax, has now swung too far in the opposite direction, say several state lawmakers and child advocates. As such, Colorado is one of a growing number of places rethinking harsh, "zero-tolerance" policies that lead to students being jailed for writing on bathroom stalls with marker and charged with felony assault for fighting in the hallway.

10/10/2011

(AustinTalks, 10/10/2011) About 50 Latino and African American parent activists from POWER-PAC (Parents Organized to Win, Educate and Renew – Policy Action Council) were joined by Ald. Walter Burnett (27th) at a bilingual rally and press conference Friday at Wells Community Academy High School, 936 N. Ashland Ave. Parents called on Chicago Public Schools (CPS) to reduce suspensions and expulsions in favor of positive alternatives, such as the parent-run Peace Center, a restorative justice program currently operating at Wells School.

10/07/2011

(Sarah Karp, Catalyst Chicago, 10/07/2011) Ald. Walter Burnett (27th Ward) told parents at a rally Friday morning that he intends to co-sponsor a resolution with Ald. Michelle Harris (8th Ward) calling on CPS to lower suspension rates by 40 percent and to implement restorative justice practices. “Rather than punish our children, we want our children to be nurtured and cared for,” he told about 40 members of POWER-PAC, a parent organization, which is part of the not-for-profit Community Organizing and Family Issues.

10/06/2011

(Kait Richmond, Pavement Pieces, 10/06/2011) Nilesh Vishwasrao should be a freshman in college, making new friends and studying English literature. Instead, he is nearly six months behind after being what he calls “pushed out” of high school. Vishwasrao, 18, of Jackson Heights, Queens, was suspended several times in high school for minor offenses, such as chewing gum or wearing a hat. But when they added up, the guidance counselor called in Vishwasrao’s father.

10/06/2011

(Viva Colorado, 10/06/2011) Decenas de miembros de la organización comunitaria Padres y Jóvenes Unidos, de Denver, se reunieron el 5 de octubre frente al capitolio estatal para presentar alternativas al sistema disciplinario escolar actual, al que consideran como "normas de castigo".

10/06/2011

(Claudia Gomez and Leslie Mendoza, The Eastside Sun, 10/06/2011) Graduating from high school is the dream of most L.A. students. We understand that education and a diploma can make the difference between a healthy, successful future and a dead-end job, or worse, the criminal justice system. But just getting to and staying in school can be a daily struggle, especially for those of us coming from the poorest communities. And when we arrive at campus, we often feel unwelcome and unmotivated in a climate where police and parole officers may outnumber counselors, and teacher layoffs create overcrowded classes.

10/05/2011

(Video Clip, Somos Noticias Colorado, 10/05/2011) Las escuelas del país cuentan con una política de cero tolerancia en cuanto a la disciplina de los estudiantes y colorado no es la excepción. Por lo que un grupo de padres y defensores de los estudiantes está protestando en estos momentos frente al capitolio estatal.

10/05/2011

(Erica Green, Baltimore Sun, 10/05/2011) A national report released today underscores the widely-known disparity in suspensions of minority students and their non-minority counterparts.In the report, Maryland is highlighted for its efforts to curb punitive suspensions and expulsions, and Baltimore is highlighted for its effort of significantly reducing its suspension rate in recent years--though the number of suspensions in the district is up this year, including those for "soft offenses" like disrespect and insubordination.

10/05/2011

(Nirvi Shah, Education Week, 10/05/2011) Black and Hispanic students are far more likely to be kicked out of school when they break the rules, including some that often have nothing to do with keeping students safe, according to a new report from a civil rights research and advocacy group.

10/05/2011

(Huffington Post, 10/05/11)Black and Latino students are disproportionately more likely to experience harsher punishments by schools for infractions and misbehaviors, according to a new report by the National Education Policy Center.

10/04/2011

(Andrew Vanacore, The Times-Picayune, 10/04/2011) Local students will share their stories about school discipline policies in New Orleans during a forum at the Treme Center tonight, an event organized by Kids Rethink New Orleans Schools and other groups.It's being put on as a part of the "Dignity in Schools Campaign National Week of Action on School Pushout."

09/28/2011

(Emily Shaw, Liz Sullivan, and Refat Shoshi Chowdhury, Op-Ed, Gotham Gazette, 09/28/2011) Luke was supposed to receive his high school diploma this year, but, like many others, he did not. A 16-year-old black student, he was placed in special education with a label of "emotional disturbance." Luke was attending a high school in District 75, the citywide district for special education, where students with disabilities are isolated from their peers without disabilities. It was not where Luke was supposed to be.

07/29/2011

(Alice Ollstein, Free Speech Radio News, 07/29/11) Youth advocates from across the country met with lawmakers on Capitol Hill this week to demand they address the so-called “school to prison pipeline.” Alice Ollstein reports.

News

05/13/2013
(The Associated Press, 05/13/13) The Los Angeles Unified School District could become the nation's first to ban suspensions of students who are willfully defiant. The school board on Tuesday is scheduled to consider the ban, which is supported by the school superintendent.
05/12/2013
(Teresa Watanabe, Los Angeles Times, 05/12/13) Damien Valentine knows painfully well about a national phenomenon that is imperiling the academic achievement of minority students, particularly African Americans like himself: the pervasive and disproportionate use of suspensions from school for mouthing off and other acts of defiance. The Manual Arts Senior High School sophomore has been suspended several times beginning in seventh grade, when he was sent home for a day and a half for refusing to change his seat because he was talking. He said the suspensions never helped him learn to control his behavior but only made him fall further behind.
05/07/2013
(Diana Lambert and Phillip Reese, Sacramento Bee, 05/07/13) Black students attending Folsom Cordova Unified schools were nearly five times as likely to be suspended as white students in the 2009-10 school year. Sacramento City Unified, Natomas Unified, Twin Rivers Unified and Elk Grove Unified all suspended black students at a rate three times higher than they suspended white students that year. Across the state, nearly one of every five African American students and one in 14 Latino students were suspended at least once in 2009-10, compared with one in 17 white students and one in 33 Asian American students, according to a report released last week from the Center for Civil Rights Remedies at UCLA.
05/01/2013
(Katy Tur, NBC News, 05/01/13) The school was plagued by violence and disorder from the start, and by 2010 it was rank in the bottom five of all public schools in the state of Massachusetts. That was when Andrew Bott — the sixth principal in seven years — showed up, and everything started to change. “We got rid of the security guards,” said Bott, who reinvested all the money used for security infrastructure into the arts.
04/18/2013
  (Editorial Board, New York Times, 04/18/13) The National Rifle Association and President Obama responded to the Newtown, Conn., shootings by recommending that more police officers be placed in the nation’s schools. But a growing body of research suggests that, contrary to popular wisdom, a larger police presence in schools generally does little to improve safety. It can also create a repressive environment in which children are arrested or issued summonses for minor misdeeds — like cutting class or talking back — that once would have been dealt with by the principal.
03/28/2013
    (By Nirvi Shah, EdWeek, 3/28/2013) In a pre-emptive move against a school safety proposal from the National Rifle Association that is expected to include a call for more people trained and approved to carry guns at schools, a coalition of civil rights groups unveiled its own safety planThursday. It seeks the creation of positive school climates, thoughtful and comprehensive crisis plans, and improved safety features that don’t turn schools into fortresses.
01/17/2013
(Campbell Robertson, New York Times, 1/17/13) Less than three months after the Justice Department sued Meridian, Miss., after finding that school students there were routinely arrested without probable cause, a report by a group of civil rights organizations says that “overly harsh school disciplinary policies” are common throughout the state.The report, which is to be released Thursday, found that in one Mississippi school district, 33 of every 1,000 children were arrested or referred to juvenile detention centers; that in another, such referrals included second and third graders; and that in yet another, only 4 percent of the law enforcement referrals were for felony-level behavior, the most often cited offense being “disorderly conduct.”
12/20/2012
(Maureen Downey, Get Schooled Blog, Atlanta Journal Constitution, 12/20/12) Along with the fiscal cliff, the United States faces an “education cliff” — the growing problem of unacceptably low graduation rates made worse, at least in part, by the reliance on school disciplinary practices that contribute to the “school to prison pipeline.” Georgia’s significantly lagging high school graduation rate is the result of many factors. A key cause may be an overuse of exclusionary discipline, such as suspensions and expulsions, and the regular referral of incidents of schoolyard misbehavior to juvenile court.
12/11/2012
(Elisabeth Kauffman, Time, 12/11/12) What do these school kids have in common? The teenage girl with a bladder disorder who left class without permission, ignoring a teacher and racing for a bathroom rather than wet herself; the boy who was rude to a school administrator; another who was tardy. They are children of color who, as a result of breaking minor school rules, were allegedly arrested and thrown into a juvenile detention facility in Meridian, Mississippi. It appears to be the most blatant case in a nationwide phenomenon that the U.S. Department of Justice, in a 37-page lawsuit, calls a “school-to-prison pipeline.”
11/26/2012
(By Julianne Hing, Colorlines, 11/26/2012) Cedrico Green can’t exactly remember how many times he went back and forth to juvenile. When asked to venture a guess he says, “Maybe 30.” He was put on probation by a youth court judge for getting into a fight when he was in eighth grade. Thereafter, any of Green’s school-based infractions, from being a few minutes late for class to breaking the school dress code by wearing the wrong color socks, counted as violations of his probation and led to his immediate suspension and incarceration in the local juvenile detention center.
10/16/2012
(Margaret Lavin, San Mateo County Times, 10/16/12) The quagmire remains how do we get students to spend more time in school while also keeping the school environment safe and productive so all students can learn. The solution is a school-wide positive behavior support system. It is a decision-making framework that guides selection, integration and implementation of the best evidenced-based practices for improving behavior outcomes for all students.
10/15/2012
(Tammerlin Drummond, Oakland Tribune Columnist, 10/15/12) African-American boys make up 17 percent of Oakland public school students but were a whopping 42 percent of those suspended. Those jarring findings released by the Urban Strategies Council in May led to a federal investigation of the Oakland school district for potential civil rights violations. As a result, Oakland school officials have agreed to allow federal monitoring of their efforts to reduce out-of-school suspensions of African-American students -- thus avoiding a federal lawsuit.
10/13/2012
(Manny Fernandez, New York Times, 10/13/12) Students identified as low-performing were transferred to charter schools, discouraged from enrolling in school or were visited at home by truant officers and told not to go to school on the test day. For some, credits were deleted from transcripts or grades were changed from passing to failing or from failing to passing so they could be reclassified as freshmen or juniors.
10/09/2012
(Nikhil Goyal, Letter to the Editor, New York Times, 10/09/12) When President George W. Bush signed No Child Left Behind into law, few would have predicted that the next decade of education policy would unfold into a disaster of epic proportions. The law was based on a flawed concept of a “good education” — high scores on standardized tests.
09/28/2012
(Associated Press, 09/28/2012) The Oakland school board has agreed to allow federal officials to monitor the district's efforts to reduce the disproportionately high suspension rates of African-American students. The school board voted 6-0 on Thursday to accept federal monitoring for at least five years at 38 schools in the Oakland Unified School District, the San Francisco Chronicle ( http://bit.ly/Qwh2T0) reported.